Computational Genomics Group
  • Home
  • Research
  • Publications
  • Teaching
  • Blog
  • Group Members
  • News
  • Computational Biology Book
  • Data Analysis with R Book
  • CG2 github
  • Fiction

in the news: Beware of ChIPs bearing gifts

2/3/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Two recent works, one  published in Plos One (Park et al. Widespread misinterpretable ChIPSeq bias in yeast) and one in PNAS (Teytelman et al.  Highly expressed loci are vulnerable to misleading ChIPlocalization of multiple unrelated proteins) 
point out a very important artifact of a very widely applied method, ChIPSeq.  Both papers that appeared almost simultaneously show that there is an inherent bias in all ChIP experiments to result in enriching regions belonging to highly-expressed genes regardless of the nature of the studied protein.

The data used: Both groups performed a series of experiments in yeast but their results may readily be extended to more complex genomes. Park et al. mostly focused on Tup1,  a well-studied transcriptional supressor, the binding of which they surprisingly found to coincide with highly-expressed genes under multiple conditions. Teytelman et al.  did the same starting from a family of repressors known as Sir proteins which they also saw to be consistently located in genes with high-expression. 

The analysis: The analysis was pretty straight-forward. ChIPSeq data from various platforms were analyzed with standard peak-calling algorithms, such as MACS2 and the discovered peaks were correlated with the expression of the closest or overlapping genes. In all cases, a positive correlation was observed even if the protein under study was not a transcriptional activator. Teytelman et al. were able to show that a positive corrrelation was even observed in the case of a GFP ChIP experiment, that is a "mock" experiment with a protein that does not bind the DNA under normal conditions. The authors, thus, reach the conclusion that the major source of bias is the process of cross-linking which is likely to occur preferentially in actively transcribed regions.   

What's next:  Both papers point out a very important aspect that has largely escaped the attention of a huge number of published works. At the same time both groups suggest the performance of extensive controls for every ChIPSeq experiment to be performed in the future. For instance, performing a "mock" ChIP with a non-DNA-binding protein such as GFP and subtracting the signal (as representative of hyper-chipability) would distinguish signal from noise. This is bound to work to a great extent but is probably not cost-worthy, while it will complicate the downstream analysis through the addition of one more condition. On the other hand, new approaches that do away with cross-linking may provide more effective solutions.

Read more: A work published this week in Nature Methods by the group of S. Henikoff describing a methodology for inquiring transcription factor binding in native (non cross-linked) chromatin (Kazinathan et al. High-resolution mapping of transcription factor binding sites on native chromatin). This is probably the next step in this sort of approaches as native chromatin does away with cross-linking which is the main source of highly-expressed gene bias.

0 Comments

    RSS Feed

    It's all about...

    Bioinformatics and computational biology with a focus on chromatin and genome architecture, plus a little bit of football and occasional aspects of  University education.

    Archives

    April 2021
    December 2020
    March 2020
    November 2018
    September 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    February 2016
    May 2015
    November 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    February 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013

    Categories

    All
    Academic Life
    Bioinformatics
    ChIPSeq
    ChIPSeq Bias
    Cpg Islands
    Data Analysis
    Exons
    Football
    Footballomics
    Gene Regulation
    Genetic Diseases
    Genome Architecture
    Genome Structure
    Inflammation
    Journalism
    Math Illiteracy
    NGS
    Nucleosome Positioning
    Nucleotide Composition
    Nucleotide Skews
    Promoters
    R
    Splicing
    Statistics
    Systems Biology
    Tnf
    Transcriptome
    Variation
    Whole Exome

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.